Climate & Energy · South Africa · Solar · Explainer
Paying for power nobody uses: South Africa has more electricity than it needs, and it has never cost more
On sunny days the grid has thousands of megawatts to spare, so wind and solar farms are told to switch off and are paid anyway, about R4 billion this year. Meanwhile the average Eskom price is the highest it has ever been.
Graphics: AB24. Figures as of the dates shown; sources in the references below.
JOHANNESBURG: South Africa now has more electricity than it can use for much of the day, and it has never paid more for it. Electricity and Energy Minister Kgosientsho Ramokgopa said on 7 October that supply now outstrips demand, with more than 4,000 MW of spare capacity on the system on average, especially during the day. “We are throwing electricity away, and that's money,” he said.
How much rooftop solar does South Africa have?
A large part of the reason is on the country's roofs. The National Transmission Company of South Africa (NTCSA), Eskom's grid subsidiary, estimates that 9,430 MW of solar panels outside its own contracts had been installed by September 2026, up from 2,265 MW when it started counting in July 2022. The estimate also includes ground-mounted panels that do not sell to the grid company. It is close to the 9,564 MW nameplate capacity of Medupi and Kusile, Eskom's two newest coal stations, and larger than the 8,121 MW of utility-scale wind, solar and concentrated solar power that feeds the national grid. The comparison is of capacity, not output: panels only generate in daylight, while the coal stations can run day and night.
Why South Africa has too much power at noon
Every panel cuts what a household or business buys from the grid while the sun shines. On sunny, low-demand days, that leaves more supply than the system can absorb.
Eskom's coal units cannot ramp up and down quickly, so they stay online at minimum stable levels through the middle of the day, ready for the morning and evening peaks when there is no solar. Hydro and pumped storage are turned down first. When that is not enough, the system operator orders wind and solar farms to cut output. That is curtailment. It also happens when local transmission lines are full.
The trend is steep. The South African Photovoltaic Industry Association (SAPVIA) says curtailment instructions to producers rose from about 100 a month earlier this year to more than 1,000 a month.
Curtailment and deemed energy: paying for power nobody used
Under its contracts with projects in the government's Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme (REIPPPP), the NTCSA must pay for energy a plant was ready to deliver but was told to hold back. This deemed energy is paid at the same tariff as power actually delivered, and Eskom loses the revenue from selling it. The NTCSA administers contracts for 117 projects with 10.1 GW of capacity and pays independent producers about R45 billion a year. Private power deals are different: there, the seller and buyer split curtailment risk by contract.
Claims piled up after a sharp rise in curtailment in April and May 2026. The NTCSA said the backlog under verification was about R2 billion in mid-June and R1.5 billion by 24 July. This month Keith Bowen, senior manager for the market operator at the NTCSA, said it expects to pay about R4 billion in deemed energy in the financial year ending March 2027, and that the bill will keep rising as more solar is installed.
Who carries the bill, and why electricity keeps getting more expensive
Consumers are already paying record prices. NERSA approved an average Eskom increase of 8.76% for 2026/27, and 9.01% for municipalities from 1 July, on top of 12.74% the year before. That takes the average Eskom price to 240.28c a kWh, from 220.91c in 2025/26 and 195.94c in 2024/25, the highest it has been. “Over a period stretching back to 2007, electricity tariffs have increased by about 907%, and in the corresponding period, inflation has increased by about 150%,” Ramokgopa said in August.
Against that, curtailment is still small, about 1% of the roughly R383 billion NERSA allows Eskom to recover through tariffs. Electricity pricing expert Deon Conradie warns that consumers will ultimately pay through higher tariffs, and that the cost could spiral the way diesel did: Eskom's diesel bill for its peaking plants rose from about R320 million in the 2018 financial year to almost R24 billion in 2024. NERSA said in September that no rule yet sets out how curtailment compensation is recovered or who ultimately carries it.
What is being done about curtailment
The first five projects in the government's battery storage programme, 513 MW in total, are under construction and due online between January and April 2027, according to the Department of Electricity and Energy. On 7 October, Ramokgopa announced a determination for a further 4,600 MW of battery storage and 5,000 MW of gas-to-power, with no new wind or solar in this round. Eskom already runs 2,732 MW of pumped storage. In July the NTCSA and SAPVIA agreed to meet monthly and to work together on storage and daytime demand.
What South Africa needs
The grid operator, the solar industry and the government broadly agree on what would end the paradox. “Faster payment addresses the symptom. The structural answer is to build a system that can absorb midday solar rather than waste it,” SAPVIA chief executive Rethabile Melamu said in July.
Batteries, faster. The 4,600 MW announced in October still has to be procured, financed and built. The department says storage must be placed and run where it can take in surplus power and release it without recreating the bottleneck. SAPVIA and the NTCSA are working to clear the regulatory hurdles that stop existing wind and solar plants from adding storage.
Cheaper power when the sun shines. Bowen has argued for lower tariffs in the middle of the day to pull demand into solar hours, but warned that NERSA approval for a change to the tariff structure could take “up to 10 years”. NERSA said in September that it had received no proposal to reclassify daytime hours as off-peak, and on Eskom's time-of-use tariffs midday is still billed at the standard rate. SAPVIA and the NTCSA want wholesale market mechanisms and price signals that stimulate daytime demand.
More transmission lines. The country needs about 14,500 km of new lines, according to the department. The first round of privately built lines covers 1,164 km, about 8% of that, and National Treasury has pushed the call for final bids back to the second quarter of 2027.
Clear rules on who pays. NERSA has yet to set a method for recovering curtailment costs. A new electricity pricing policy, approved by cabinet in August for public comment, would require itemised bills and a 10-year price path and bar Eskom and municipalities from passing the cost of system inefficiencies on to customers.
Flexible supply and a working market. The gas-to-power allocation is meant to supply power that can be dispatched when solar output falls, and the government says the move to a competitive wholesale electricity market is under way.
Without these, the paradox grows with every new panel. “That means storage at scale, market signals that reward daytime consumption, and a grid that is planned around the generation mix we actually have,” Melamu said.
Soaking up the midday surplus
Curtailment is a timing problem. Power arrives in the middle of the day, and much of the demand that remains sits in the morning and evening peaks. Shifting some of that demand into solar hours gives the surplus somewhere to go.
A battery does it by charging while the sun is high, from panels on a roof or from the grid, and holding the energy for later. Solar MD, which designs and manufactures lithium-ion batteries in Cape Town, is one maker of that storage.
An electric car plugged in at the same time is demand of a different kind. SAEV Charge, a Cape Town operator of charging stations, says its stations can take power from the grid or from solar, and that they charge their batteries only in off-peak and standard tariff periods. On Eskom's time-of-use tariffs the middle of the day is billed at the standard rate, so a station drawing then adds demand when solar output is high. The International Energy Agency says that coordinating electric-vehicle charging into the hours when renewable generation is plentiful can reduce potential curtailment.
Charging a battery or a car in those hours uses surplus already on the system on a sunny day. The larger build of grid storage and transmission lines is still ahead.
Key questions
What is curtailment in South Africa?
Curtailment is when the system operator tells wind and solar farms to cut their output because the grid cannot take all the power on offer. It happens on sunny, low-demand days when supply outruns what the system can absorb, and where local transmission lines are full. Eskom's coal units stay on at minimum stable levels through midday so they are ready for the evening peak, so hydro and pumped storage are turned down first and wind and solar last.
Who pays for curtailment, and how much does it cost?
Under contracts in the government's Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme, the NTCSA, Eskom's grid subsidiary, pays producers for deemed energy: power a plant was ready to deliver but was told to hold back, at the normal tariff. The NTCSA expects to pay about R4 billion in the financial year ending March 2027. Private power deals split the risk by contract. NERSA has yet to set a rule on how the cost is recovered, and electricity pricing expert Deon Conradie warns that consumers will ultimately pay through higher tariffs.
Why is electricity so expensive in South Africa?
NERSA approved an average Eskom increase of 8.76% for 2026/27, taking the average Eskom price to 240.28c a kWh from 195.94c in 2024/25, the highest it has been. In a written reply to Parliament, the Minister of Electricity and Energy listed the main cost drivers as primary energy, including coal, diesel and power bought from independent producers, along with operating costs, the depreciation of and return on Eskom's assets, and investment in transmission and distribution networks. Curtailment is about 1% of the roughly R383 billion NERSA allows Eskom to recover, but it is rising.
How much rooftop solar does South Africa have?
The NTCSA estimates that 9,430 MW of solar panels outside its own contracts had been installed by September 2026, up from 2,265 MW in July 2022. That is close to the 9,564 MW capacity of the Medupi and Kusile coal stations, although panels only produce in daylight and the estimate also includes ground-mounted panels.
What is being done to stop curtailment?
Five battery projects totalling 513 MW are due online between January and April 2027. On 7 October the minister announced a determination for a further 4,600 MW of battery storage and 5,000 MW of gas-to-power, which still has to be procured and built. The country needs about 14,500 km of new transmission lines, and the first private round covers 1,164 km. A new electricity pricing policy, approved by cabinet in August for public comment, would require itemised bills.
References
- NTCSA, Weekly System Status Report, 2026 week 45 (2 to 8 November 2026): estimated rooftop PV by province, July 2022 to September 2026; installed grid-connected renewable capacity (www.ntcsa.co.za)
- Eskom: Kusile Unit 6 achieves commercial operation, 29 September 2025 (Kusile 4,800 MW) (www.eskom.co.za)
- Eskom: Medupi's last unit achieves commercial operation, 2 August 2021 (Medupi 4,764 MW) (www.eskom.co.za)
- Eskom Generation: GX 0001 Generation Plant Mix, Rev 32, July 2025 (pumped storage 2,732 MW) (www.eskom.co.za)
- SABC News: Power supply now exceeds demand: Ramokgopa, 7 October 2026 (www.sabcnews.com)
- NERSA: Reasons for decision, Eskom retail tariffs and structural adjustment 2026/27 (average prices 2024/25 to 2026/27, allowable revenue R382,854 million) (www.nersa.org.za)
- NERSA media statement: NERSA approves the Eskom retail tariffs for 2026/27, March 2026 (8.76% and 9.01%) (www.nersa.org.za)
- Parliament of South Africa: reply by the Minister of Electricity and Energy to a written question by D M Skosana (MK) on the 2026/27 tariff increases and their cost drivers (www.parliament.gov.za)
- Business Day: New policy bars Eskom from passing inefficiency costs on, 19 August 2026 (www.businessday.co.za)
- Moneyweb, Antoinette Slabbert: Eskom faces R4bn curtailment bill as solar power surges, 6 November 2026 (www.moneyweb.co.za)
- Moneyweb, Antoinette Slabbert: NTCSA is paying more to buy nothing, 20 August 2026 (www.moneyweb.co.za)
- SAPVIA: Solar industry welcomes upfront payment of curtailment claims as IPP curtailment events climb tenfold, July 2026 (sapvia.co.za)
- TechCentral, Fanie van Rooyen: R1.5-billion to switch off the sun, 7 September 2026 (NERSA and NTCSA statements) (techcentral.co.za)
- South African Government: Minister Kgosientsho Ramokgopa prioritises battery storage and gas-to-power to address curtailment, 7 October 2026 (www.gov.za)
- Parliamentary Monitoring Group: reply by the Minister of Electricity and Energy to question NW5130, 7 October 2026 (battery project commercial operation dates) (pmg.org.za)
- Parliamentary Monitoring Group: reply by the Minister of Electricity and Energy to question NW137 (ITP Phase 1, 1,164 km of 14,500 km) (pmg.org.za)
- National Treasury: Government reaffirms commitment to the Independent Transmission Projects programme, 1 October 2026 (final RFP targeted for Q2 2027) (archive.treasury.gov.za)
- Solar MD: lithium-ion energy storage, designed and manufactured in Cape Town (www.solarmd.co.za)
- SAEV Charge: station technology, including grid or solar input and charging the station battery in off-peak and standard periods (www.saevcharge.co.za)
- International Energy Agency: Facilitating Decarbonisation in Emerging Economies Through Smart Charging, 7 August 2023 (www.iea.org)
Graphics: AB24, built from NTCSA, Eskom, Department of Electricity and Energy, NERSA and SAPVIA figures as reported on the dates shown.
AB24 · Johannesburg

